In this article, I will discuss the broaching resistance of three common propulsion systems for small vessels. Please note that sailboats are not included in this analysis.
The propulsion systems for small vessels typically fall into three categories: outboard, inboard (referred to as shaft-driven boats), and sterndrive boats (referred to as drive boats). (For more details on each system’s pros and cons, click here to check the relevant links.)
The content presented here reflects Rikutsu Konetaro’s personal opinions, so please consider it as a reference rather than definitive advice.
Contents
What is broaching resistance?
Broaching refers to a phenomenon that can lead to capsizing. In this article, I’ll explore the resistance of small vessel propulsion systems to broaching. Specifically, I will define broaching resistance as the ability of the rudder to maintain control when broaching occurs.
However, broaching resistance is not the same as capsize resistance. A boat can have low broaching resistance but still be difficult to capsize. So, please read this article as just one perspective and not as absolute fact.
Conclusion: Are shaft-driven boats more prone to broaching?
In my opinion, shaft-driven boats seem to have the lowest resistance to broaching. This is because the loss of rudder effectiveness during broaching is most noticeable in shaft-driven boats.
When the boat’s speed matches that of the waves from behind, there is no water flow around the rudder, causing it to lose control, making it difficult to maintain or change course. In other words, when the boat’s speed and the wave’s speed align, it becomes hard to control the boat’s direction in a shaft-driven vessel.
On the other hand, sterndrive and outboard boats can change direction by adjusting the angle of the propeller. As long as the propeller is spinning, even at low water speeds, these boats can maintain or change course, functioning almost like a thruster.
Advantages of sterndrive and outboard boats
Sterndrive and outboard boats have the advantage of being able to steer by adjusting the propeller’s angle, making it easier to change the boat’s direction even during broaching. As long as the propeller remains in the water, these boats can maintain or change course, giving them a higher broaching resistance compared to shaft-driven boats.
Are shaft-driven boats more stable?
However, shaft-driven boats may have a lower risk of capsizing due to their lower center of gravity, as the engine is typically installed lower in the boat. Even if they struggle with broaching, shaft-driven boats might be less likely to capsize. If they avoid capsizing, they may still be able to return safely to port despite the challenges of broaching.
Is a sterndrive boat the best choice? It’s not that simple.
Sterndrive boats may offer both high broaching resistance and capsize resistance, but they are not necessarily the ideal choice for everyone. Factors such as maintenance costs and exposure to seawater must be considered, making the decision more complex. (For more details, refer to the link here.)
In any case, when it comes to broaching resistance, shaft-driven boats might be somewhat more vulnerable than the other types—this is my current view as of October 13, 2024.
That’s all for now.