This page explores the three main propulsion methods for small boats and their respective resistance to broaching. Note that yachts are excluded from the discussion.
Small boat propulsion methods generally fall into three categories: “outboard motor boats,” “inboard motor boats (hereinafter referred to as shaft boats),” and “inboard-outboard motor boats (hereinafter referred to as drive boats).” (For more details, advantages, and disadvantages of each type, please refer to the provided link.)
The content presented here is based on the author’s personal views and should be taken as a reference only.
Contents
What is broaching resistance?
Broaching refers to a hazardous maneuvering condition that occurs when small boats or yachts are subjected to rough seas or waves, particularly when waves hit from a diagonal rear direction. This phenomenon primarily occurs when the boat descends a wave’s slope and exhibits the following characteristics:
- Loss of maneuverability due to wave forces
When the stern is pushed by wave forces, the boat’s direction turns sideways relative to the waves, causing instability. - Loss of steering control
Strong wave action can prevent the boat from maintaining its heading, rendering the steering ineffective. This leads to a loss of control, increasing the danger. - Risk of capsizing or overturning
When the boat is turned sideways to the waves, it becomes more susceptible to lateral forces from the waves, heightening the risk of capsizing or overturning.
This discussion focuses on the loss of steering control and examines the broaching resistance of different propulsion methods. Since the mechanisms for steering differ by propulsion type, boats that maintain effective steering during broaching are described as having “high broaching resistance.” However, it is important to note that broaching resistance and capsizing resistance are distinct concepts; some boats with low broaching resistance may still be less prone to capsizing. Therefore, this article should be viewed as one perspective among many.
When the speed of the waves matches the speed of the boat from behind, shaft boats experience a lack of water flow around the rudder, causing the rudder to lose effectiveness. Consequently, maintaining or changing the course becomes difficult. Especially when ground speed and wave speed are aligned, shaft boats struggle to control their direction.
On the other hand, drive boats and outboard motor boats can change course by adjusting the direction of their propellers. As long as the propellers are spinning, even at low relative water speeds, they can maintain or alter the course, effectively serving as thrusters.
Source of broaching resistance in drive boats and outboard motor boats
Drive boats and outboard motor boats have an advantage in broaching situations because they rely on the direction of their propellers to steer. As long as the propellers are operational, they can maintain or change course more easily, making them more resistant to broaching compared to shaft boats, which depend solely on rudders.
Potential for high capsizing resistance in shaft boats
Shaft boats often feature lower engine placement, resulting in a lower center of gravity. This design may enhance stability and make them less likely to capsize even if affected by broaching. If capsizing is avoided, a shaft boat might endure the challenges of broaching and safely return to port.
Are drive boats optimal? The choice is not straightforward
Drive boats may offer high resistance to both broaching and capsizing, but they are not always the optimal choice. Factors such as durability against seawater and maintenance costs must also be considered. (For details, click here.)
In any case, regarding broaching resistance alone, shaft boats appear to be more vulnerable compared to other propulsion methods. This represents the author’s view as of October 13, 2024.
That concludes this discussion.
For other content on this site, please click the links below:
Table Of Content By Topic
PagesAbout Boating and Sailing
Pages About GR Yaris
Pages About OMDS (formerly Olympus) OM-1
Pages About Nissan Note e-POWER 4WD Pages About Life Hacks for Smooth Living
Pages About Second LIfe